Parental Income Threshold for Need-Based Aid Forum

[cyclawps]

I have to disclose parental financial information in applying for need-based aid. I am low-income and financially independent, and I won't be receiving any financial support from my parents for law school. Is there a general parental income/asset threshold at which it would 1) be either a waste of my time to apply for need-based aid, or 2) be detrimental to my merit-based aid chances? If anyone has any specific information on need-based aid from Berkeley, that'd be most helpful.

[cavalier1138]

Need-based aid is a black box at almost every school. But the good news is that you probably won't qualify unless you're well below the poverty line.

[Mr_Chukes]

Need-based aid is a black box at almost every school. But the good news is that you probably won't qualify unless you're well below the poverty line.

I just have a simple question. How are people able to tell others that they "probably" won't qualify if each school is a black box?

[cavalier1138]

Need-based aid is a black box at almost every school. But the good news is that you probably won't qualify unless you're well below the poverty line.

I just have a simple question. How are people able to tell others that they "probably" won't qualify if each school is a black box?

Because schools are pretty transparent when it comes to need-based aid: no one gets it.

[TAD]

Need-based aid is a black box at almost every school. But the good news is that you probably won't qualify unless you're well below the poverty line.

I just have a simple question. How are people able to tell others that they "probably" won't qualify if each school is a black box?

Because schools are pretty transparent when it comes to need-based aid: no one gets it.

I'm assuming your statement excludes HYS, correct? Or does it still apply? I assumed lower middle class would still get a decent amount from these schools?

[Mr_Chukes]

Need-based aid is a black box at almost every school. But the good news is that you probably won't qualify unless you're well below the poverty line.

I just have a simple question. How are people able to tell others that they "probably" won't qualify if each school is a black box?

Because schools are pretty transparent when it comes to need-based aid: no one gets it.

I'm assuming your statement excludes HYS, correct? Or does it still apply? I assumed lower middle class would still get a decent amount from these schools?

It means don't listen to people on the internet and just apply.

[cavalier1138]

Need-based aid is a black box at almost every school. But the good news is that you probably won't qualify unless you're well below the poverty line.

I just have a simple question. How are people able to tell others that they "probably" won't qualify if each school is a black box?

Because schools are pretty transparent when it comes to need-based aid: no one gets it.

I'm assuming your statement excludes HYS, correct? Or does it still apply? I assumed lower middle class would still get a decent amount from these schools?

It means don't listen to people on the internet and just apply.

It means use your brain and don't assume that someone's including HYS (the only three schools in the nation that don't give merit aid) in the general description of how schools calculate need-based aid. Honestly, did you think that anyone was discussing HYS prior to it being raised as a separate question?

Now, to answer the question and not the idiotic "critique": HYS may grant need-based aid to "lower-middle class" families, but if you're using the term "middle class" in there, I doubt you'll get offered much, especially from Harvard. Check out the 509s from each of these schools to get an idea of how common significant aid is.

[Mr_Chukes]

Need-based aid is a black box at almost every school. But the good news is that you probably won't qualify unless you're well below the poverty line.

I just have a simple question. How are people able to tell others that they "probably" won't qualify if each school is a black box?

Because schools are pretty transparent when it comes to need-based aid: no one gets it.

I'm assuming your statement excludes HYS, correct? Or does it still apply? I assumed lower middle class would still get a decent amount from these schools?

It means don't listen to people on the internet and just apply.

It means use your brain and don't assume that someone's including HYS (the only three schools in the nation that don't give merit aid) in the general description of how schools calculate need-based aid. Honestly, did you think that anyone was discussing HYS prior to it being raised as a separate question?

Now, to answer the question and not the idiotic "critique": HYS may grant need-based aid to "lower-middle class" families, but if you're using the term "middle class" in there, I doubt you'll get offered much, especially from Harvard. Check out the 509s from each of these schools to get an idea of how common significant aid is.

No the problem is you are giving information based on assumptions. You don't know how the need aid works that's why you called it a black box. At the same time you assume that you know how it works. I feel that the way you express your view, you are discouraging him from applying. You may not be doing this on purpose but when I read it I get this feeling.

What he needs to do is call the schools financial aid offices and discuss how merit aid works with them. I do agree with checking the 509s.

Just be realistic and expect to not get much aid if any.

[TAD]

I doubt you'll get offered much, especially from Harvard. Check out the 509s from each of these schools to get an idea of how common significant aid is.

Ah, damn. Okay cool, thanks.