You really think it's worth $50k more for NYC biglaw?jbagelboy wrote:If you get Penn at $105k, I'd probably do that. Otherwise Cornell.
Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake Forum
-
- Posts: 16639
- Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2014 3:19 pm
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
- mtf612
- Posts: 246
- Joined: Thu May 19, 2016 1:56 am
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
I received the 105k today. Going to ask for a bit more. They want an answer by Monday with withdrawal everywhere else I have been admitted. I honestly liked Penn's ASW more than the other three schools and it felt like the best "fit." I'm a city guy, from a sunny state, and being isolated in Ithaca does not seem like a healthy choice for me personally.jbagelboy wrote:If you get Penn at $105k, I'd probably do that. Otherwise Cornell.
If I end up getting an admit off hold at CLS, ever hear a decision from NYU, or get off the Chicago/Harvard waitlist then my decision tree will obviously change. As much as I want biglaw now, the clerkship/networtking/lay prestige opportunities afforded by HLS make it worth the extra $110k of cost over Penn IMHO.
For those advising retake -I'm spending this saturday taking PT80 to find out where I stand. If I'm not totally rusty, I'll register for June and try to crank out a couple of more points...no better way to spend my birthday than taking the June LSAT
- melmelcoolj
- Posts: 428
- Joined: Fri Apr 15, 2016 5:43 am
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
You cannot get into Wachtell from NYU? That just seems a little weird given Wachtell's partners often serve on NYU Law's board.lilitiger99 wrote:Why would you be mistaken? Cornell at nearly a full ride for NYC big law seems like a no brainer.
I know people on here can be prestige whores, but from talking to real life lawyers and the lawyers on here, everyone is going to say take the money and a lower t13 rather than pay sticker at Columbia, NYU, etc.
I'm most likely turning down my t6 offers @ sticker to go to Duke or Cornell depending which one will scholarship match, and I was at Cornell's ASW and was very impressed. Their employment offers & Big law stats are very good, though apparently only Columbia and up will get you Watchell etc.
-
- Posts: 170
- Joined: Tue Apr 11, 2017 12:34 am
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
Of course WLRK takes NYU people. And Columbia people. Is it likely from either? No.melmelcoolj wrote:You cannot get into Wachtell from NYU? That just seems a little weird given Wachtell's partners often serve on NYU Law's board.lilitiger99 wrote:Why would you be mistaken? Cornell at nearly a full ride for NYC big law seems like a no brainer.
I know people on here can be prestige whores, but from talking to real life lawyers and the lawyers on here, everyone is going to say take the money and a lower t13 rather than pay sticker at Columbia, NYU, etc.
I'm most likely turning down my t6 offers @ sticker to go to Duke or Cornell depending which one will scholarship match, and I was at Cornell's ASW and was very impressed. Their employment offers & Big law stats are very good, though apparently only Columbia and up will get you Watchell etc.
- cavalier1138
- Posts: 8007
- Joined: Fri Mar 25, 2016 8:01 pm
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
It's not likely from Yale. Wachtell only takes the top of the class from a very small grouping of schools, and it's a pointless metric to use.ernie wrote:Of course WLRK takes NYU people. And Columbia people. Is it likely from either? No.melmelcoolj wrote:You cannot get into Wachtell from NYU? That just seems a little weird given Wachtell's partners often serve on NYU Law's board.lilitiger99 wrote:Why would you be mistaken? Cornell at nearly a full ride for NYC big law seems like a no brainer.
I know people on here can be prestige whores, but from talking to real life lawyers and the lawyers on here, everyone is going to say take the money and a lower t13 rather than pay sticker at Columbia, NYU, etc.
I'm most likely turning down my t6 offers @ sticker to go to Duke or Cornell depending which one will scholarship match, and I was at Cornell's ASW and was very impressed. Their employment offers & Big law stats are very good, though apparently only Columbia and up will get you Watchell etc.
Want to continue reading?
Register now to search topics and post comments!
Absolutely FREE!
Already a member? Login
- mtf612
- Posts: 246
- Joined: Thu May 19, 2016 1:56 am
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
Penn came up to 126. Depositing there and withdrawing elsewhere happily!
-
- Posts: 203
- Joined: Mon Mar 27, 2017 8:04 pm
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
I have no dog in this fight. OP seems to care a lot about prestige though, so that might translate into firms/where they take people from, etc. Just echoing what I've heard from various partners/friends of friends around the area.cavalier1138 wrote:It's not likely from Yale. Wachtell only takes the top of the class from a very small grouping of schools, and it's a pointless metric to use.ernie wrote:Of course WLRK takes NYU people. And Columbia people. Is it likely from either? No.melmelcoolj wrote:You cannot get into Wachtell from NYU? That just seems a little weird given Wachtell's partners often serve on NYU Law's board.lilitiger99 wrote:Why would you be mistaken? Cornell at nearly a full ride for NYC big law seems like a no brainer.
I know people on here can be prestige whores, but from talking to real life lawyers and the lawyers on here, everyone is going to say take the money and a lower t13 rather than pay sticker at Columbia, NYU, etc.
I'm most likely turning down my t6 offers @ sticker to go to Duke or Cornell depending which one will scholarship match, and I was at Cornell's ASW and was very impressed. Their employment offers & Big law stats are very good, though apparently only Columbia and up will get you Watchell etc.
Not sure why a 0L would be any firm or bust anyway, but if he cares about rankings & such, might matter to him.
- jbagelboy
- Posts: 10361
- Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2012 7:57 pm
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
congrats. I think that's the right choice.mtf612 wrote:Penn came up to 126. Depositing there and withdrawing elsewhere happily!
I also think this is the right choice over "higher ranked" schools that would make you pay sticker price, btw. Don't be flippant about your goals and fall into that classic law school trap of chasing whatever goal seems most sparkly just because you "can." You have a terrific outcome right now.
- mtf612
- Posts: 246
- Joined: Thu May 19, 2016 1:56 am
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
Thanks! I will standby and say that if HLS calls in June that I would seriously consider it. I'm first gen and have a no name undergrad degree so I am a bit of a prestige whore. But I'm stoked on penn right now!jbagelboy wrote:congrats. I think that's the right choice.mtf612 wrote:Penn came up to 126. Depositing there and withdrawing elsewhere happily!
I also think this is the right choice over "higher ranked" schools that would make you pay sticker price, btw. Don't be flippant about your goals and fall into that classic law school trap of chasing whatever goal seems most sparkly just because you "can." You have a terrific outcome right now.
-
- Posts: 170
- Joined: Tue Apr 11, 2017 12:34 am
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
Penn is plenty prestigious. In any event, if HLS calls in June, call Penn back and get them to up their offer. That's the smart move.mtf612 wrote:Thanks! I will standby and say that if HLS calls in June that I would seriously consider it. I'm first gen and have a no name undergrad degree so I am a bit of a prestige whore. But I'm stoked on penn right now!
- mtf612
- Posts: 246
- Joined: Thu May 19, 2016 1:56 am
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
Haha also definitely a considerationernie wrote:Penn is plenty prestigious. In any event, if HLS calls in June, call Penn back and get them to up their offer. That's the smart move.mtf612 wrote:Thanks! I will standby and say that if HLS calls in June that I would seriously consider it. I'm first gen and have a no name undergrad degree so I am a bit of a prestige whore. But I'm stoked on penn right now!
- Pragmatic Gun
- Posts: 1361
- Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2013 3:25 pm
Re: Cornell / Northwestern / Duke / Penn / Retake
Wachtell's founding partners are NYU graduates and founded the firm relatively recently (1965). Why wouldn't they have a pipeline from their alma mater which is prestigious to begin with?
Register now!
Resources to assist law school applicants, students & graduates.
It's still FREE!
Already a member? Login